Navigating the colorful but dangerous streets of Sanctuary in Borderlands 2 often brings unexpected tactical challenges that test your deduction skills rather than just your firepower. The optional mission titled Won't Get Fooled Again tasks players with solving a classic whodunit murder mystery in the heart of the city. Successfully identifying the true culprit among four identical brothers requires analyzing specific clues given by local residents.
Starting the Investigation in Sanctuary
To begin this unique detective assignment, players must locate Marshall Friedman standing outside of Moxxxi's bar after completing the main story mission titled The Bright Lights, Flying City. The lawman explains that a murder has taken place, but he lacks the time to properly cross-examine the four potential suspects gathered nearby. By accepting the mission, you are officially deputized to interview the local witnesses and solve the crime yourself.
The four suspects, known as the Gutter quadruplets, stand in a line waiting for your final judgment. Accusing the wrong brother does not fail the mission entirely, but finding the correct answer on your first attempt showcases your analytical abilities. Preparing your mental checklist before talking to the local business owners ensures a swift resolution.
Analyzing the Witness Statements
Your primary goal is to gather reliable testimonies from three prominent figures in Sanctuary, starting with Moxxi, Dr. Zed, and Marcus. Moxxi reveals that she shot the criminal three times, noting that the first two rounds hit his energy shield before the third bullet finally caused a physical injury. This critical piece of information confirms that the true killer must possess a functioning shield system and currently shows signs of taking damage.
Next, visiting Dr. Zed provides the medical context needed to narrow down the list of suspects. The doctor states that he recently treated one of the brothers for a gunshot wound, meaning the culprit has been patched up back to full health. Lastly, Marcus mentions hearing only a single gunshot from the crime scene, effectively ruling out any weapons capable of burst fire or heavy explosive damage.
Identifying the True Culprit
Combining these three distinct clues allows you to inspect the physical attributes of the four brothers using your weapon reticle. You need to look closely at their individual combat gear, shield status indicators, and current health pools. The correct choice is always the brother equipped with a sniper rifle, who possesses a full shield and a full health bar.
This specific combination perfectly aligns with the witness accounts because a sniper fires a single decisive bullet per trigger pull. Furthermore, his active shield matches Moxxi's story, while his full health confirms he received treatment from Dr. Zed after being wounded. Choosing the sniper brother immediately forces the guilty party to confess to the crime.
Claiming Your Law Pistol Reward
Once you accurately accuse the sniper brother, Marshall Friedman commends your excellent police work and hands over your well-deserved reward. Players receive a unique rare handgun known as the Law, which features a prominent blade attached to the barrel. This specific weapon is highly coveted by melee-focused character builds due to its massive increase to physical striking damage.
The Law pistol also boasts exceptional accuracy and fires as fast as you can pull the trigger, making it a reliable sidearm for various combat encounters. Completing this side mission provides both a fascinating narrative break and an incredibly powerful tool for your ongoing journey through Pandora.